OverYou

15 Breakup Myths, Checked Against the Research

· 10 min read · Getting over a breakup

Mochi the cat popping a big soap bubble with one claw, looking satisfied

Last reviewed November 2026. This is a review of published research and our own search-trends study, not new research. Verdicts: True (good evidence for it), False (good evidence against it), Partly true (true in some cases or in a weaker form), No evidence (no study supports it). Full references are at the end.

When your heart is broken, everyone has a rule for you: it takes half the length of the relationship, rebounds never work, they'll come back if you go silent. Some of these are comforting, some are frightening, and most have never been tested. We checked 15 of the most common breakup myths against the research.

The 15 myths at a glance

MythVerdict
It takes half the length of the relationship to get over itNo evidence
No contact makes your ex come backNo evidence
Rebounds always failFalse
Men get over breakups fasterNo evidence
The person who ends it doesn't hurtFalse
You need closure from your ex to move onFalse
There's a breakup seasonNo evidence
Staying friends right away is healthyPartly true
Cutting off social media doesn't matterFalse
Time heals everything on its ownPartly true
Writing about it always helpsFalse
You'll never love like that againNo evidence
Getting back together usually worksFalse
Heartbreak is "just emotional"False
The stages of grief happen in orderPartly true

Key facts

Mochi the cat inspecting a note through a big magnifying glass

Myth: It takes half the length of the relationship to get over it

Verdict: No evidence. No study has found that recovery time is a fixed fraction of how long you were together.

What studies do show is that feelings change faster than the rule suggests. In a diary study of 58 young adults who were signalled at random for 28 days after a breakup, love for the ex declined steadily over that month, and sadness and anger followed curved patterns, highest early on (Sbarra and Emery, 2005). People also tend to overestimate how distressed they'll be after a breakup (Eastwick and colleagues, 2008). Some things do make it harder: in Rhoades and colleagues' 2011 study, having lived together or planned to marry went with bigger drops in life satisfaction. There's more in how long it takes to get over someone.

Myth: No contact makes your ex come back

Verdict: No evidence. No study has tested whether no contact makes an ex return, and it isn't designed to.

No contact is a recovery tool. In the same diary study, contact with a former partner slowed the decline of love and sadness (Sbarra and Emery, 2005). Used as a tactic, it tends to backfire on its own terms, because you spend the time waiting for a reaction. Our review of whether no contact works and the guide will my ex come back? cover this in detail.

Myth: Rebounds always fail

Verdict: False. In two studies, people in new relationships after a breakup were more confident in their desirability and had more resolution over their ex, and starting sooner went with better psychological health (Brumbaugh and Fraley, 2015).

Rhoades and colleagues (2011) found something similar in 1,295 unmarried adults: having begun to date someone new went with a smaller drop in life satisfaction after a breakup. These studies are correlational, so healthier people may simply date sooner. A rebound used to avoid your feelings or to make an ex jealous is a different thing. See rebound relationships and when to start dating again.

Myth: Men get over breakups faster

Verdict: No evidence. In a large German study of 1,530 people who went through a separation, there were no gender differences in how much well-being or loneliness changed (Psychology and Aging, 2025).

That study did find other differences: men were less likely to start the separation, less satisfied with being single and wished for a new partner more. In a smaller US study of 193 people, women reported more negative emotions such as sadness and confusion after a breakup (Perilloux and Buss, 2008). So men and women may show it differently, but there's no good evidence that men recover faster. Our guide to getting over a breakup as a man goes further.

Myth: The person who ends it doesn't hurt

Verdict: False. The person who ends a relationship usually hurts less than the person who was left, but they do hurt.

In Perilloux and Buss's 2008 study, people who were rejected reported more depression, loss of self-esteem and rumination, while rejectors bore the cost of being seen as cruel by others. In a larger study, recipients reported more distress than the people who ended things (Koessler and colleagues, 2019). Guilt, doubt and grief are common for the one who leaves; see getting over a breakup you initiated.

Myth: You need closure from your ex to move on

Verdict: False. Recovery depends much more on how you relate to yourself than on a final conversation with your ex.

In a study of 109 divorcing adults, those who spoke about their separation with more self-compassion had fewer intrusive thoughts and feelings about it, an effect that lasted up to nine months (Sbarra and colleagues, 2012). In another study of 210 recently separated young adults, those assigned to answer questions about their breakup at four lab visits over nine weeks regained a clearer sense of who they were, which explained drops in loneliness and intrusive thoughts (Larson and Sbarra, 2015). Neither involved the ex. See how to get closure after a breakup.

Myth: There's a breakup season

Verdict: No evidence. In five years of US Google Trends data, searches for "breakup", "get over ex" and "miss my ex" stayed within about 10% of normal in every month (OverYou, 2026).

Divorce is different: in the same data, "divorce lawyer" searches ran about 30% higher in June than in December, and divorce searches dipped over the holidays and rose in early January. Search interest isn't the same as breakups happening, but it doesn't show a season. Full results in our breakup and divorce search trends study.

Myth: Staying friends right away is healthy

Verdict: Partly true. It depends on why you stay friends.

In two studies, friendships with an ex kept for security or practical reasons had more positive outcomes, while friendships kept because of unresolved romantic feelings had negative outcomes (Griffith and colleagues, 2017). Marshall's 2012 study found a similar mix online: people who stayed Facebook friends with an ex reported less longing but also less personal growth. If you're secretly hoping for more, friendship right away usually keeps the wound open. See should I be friends with my ex?

Myth: Cutting off social media doesn't matter

Verdict: False. Checking an ex's profiles is one of the most consistent predictors of slower recovery in breakup research.

Marshall (2012) found that surveillance of an ex went with more distress, longing and negative feelings and less growth, even after accounting for offline contact. Among 256 people, the 61% who did little or no monitoring had the least distress (McDaniel and colleagues, 2021), and in a survey of 431 people, distress predicted more monitoring, especially for those who didn't start the breakup (Fox and Tokunaga, 2015). Muting works if you also stop looking. See should I unfollow my ex? and how to stop checking their Instagram.

Myth: Time heals everything on its own

Verdict: Partly true. Most people do recover with time, but what you do with that time changes how fast.

A major review argued that resilience after loss is more common than psychologists used to believe (Bonanno, 2004), and in Sbarra and Emery's diary study, love and sadness faded over the first month. But contact with the ex slowed that fading, and self-compassion predicted better recovery months later (Sbarra and colleagues, 2012). Time does the most when you stop reopening the wound. Our overview of the science of getting over a breakup gathers the research on what helps. If weeks pass and you're not eating, sleeping or functioning, read when breakup sadness needs help.

Myth: Writing about it always helps

Verdict: False. Some kinds of writing help, and one kind made recovery worse for some people.

In a randomized study of 90 recently separated adults, people who were still actively searching for meaning in their separation had worse emotional outcomes up to nine months later when assigned to expressive writing about their feelings, compared with neutral writing (Sbarra and colleagues, 2013). In contrast, positive-focused writing about a breakup raised positive emotions in a randomized study of 87 people (Lewandowski, 2009). See does writing about a breakup help?

Myth: You'll never love like that again

Verdict: No evidence. No study shows that a lost love can't be matched, and people are bad at predicting how they'll feel.

People tend to overestimate how much distress a breakup will cause (Eastwick and colleagues, 2008). In a study of 92 students who had recently broken up, people reported on average five types of personal growth that they thought might improve future relationships (Tashiro and Frazier, 2003). The feeling that this was the one is real, and it's also one of the most common feelings in grief. See will I ever get over my ex?

Myth: Getting back together usually works

Verdict: False. On average, couples who break up and get back together report more problems, and the more often it happens, the worse it gets.

Almost two thirds of 445 US students had been in an on-off relationship; on-off partners reported more uncertainty and communication problems, and more renewals went with more negatives (Dailey and colleagues, 2009). In a national sample of 1,075 couples, those who had cycled were at higher risk of cycling again and reported lower satisfaction (Vennum and colleagues, 2014). Some couples do make it work, usually when something real has changed. See on-and-off relationships and should I get back with my ex?

Myth: Heartbreak is "just emotional"

Verdict: False. Rejection activates brain areas that process physical pain, and extreme emotional stress can affect the heart.

When people who'd recently been through an unwanted breakup looked at a photo of their ex, brain areas linked to the sensory side of physical pain became active (Kross and colleagues, 2011). Looking at an ex also activates reward and craving systems (Fisher and colleagues, 2010). In rare cases, sudden emotional stress can cause "broken heart syndrome", a temporary weakening of the heart muscle (Wittstein and colleagues, 2005). Chest pain or trouble breathing needs emergency care. See physical symptoms of a breakup and why breakups hurt so much.

Myth: The stages of grief happen in order

Verdict: Partly true. Grief responses rise and fall roughly in the familiar sequence on average, but they overlap heavily and acceptance is present from the start.

In a study of 233 bereaved people, the five grief indicators peaked in the order the stage model predicts, but acceptance was the most common response throughout and yearning, not disbelief, was the strongest negative feeling (Maciejewski and colleagues, 2007). That study was about the death of a family member, not a breakup, so it's a guide, not a map. See the stages of a breakup.

What the research does and doesn't show

How OverYou helps

OverYou is built around the findings that hold up: a no contact streak with a daily check-in, an "I'm tempted" pause for the moments you want to check their profile, and Don't Send It for messages that never leave your phone. Mochi, the app's AI coach, is there when an old myth is getting loud. It's self-care, not therapy.

Sources

  1. Personal Relationships (2005). The emotional sequelae of nonmarital relationship dissolution: Analysis of change and intraindividual variability over time
  2. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships (2015). Too fast, too soon? An empirical investigation into rebound relationships
  3. Psychology and Aging (2025). Men and women transitioning to singlehood in young adulthood and midlife
  4. Psychological Science (2012). When leaving your ex, love yourself: observational ratings of self-compassion predict the course of emotional recovery following marital separation
  5. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking (2012). Facebook surveillance of former romantic partners: associations with postbreakup recovery and personal growth
  6. Clinical Psychological Science (2013). Expressive writing can impede emotional recovery following marital separation
  7. Personal Relationships (2009). On-again/off-again dating relationships: How are they different from other dating relationships?
  8. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2011). Social rejection shares somatosensory representations with physical pain
  9. JAMA (2007). An Empirical Examination of the Stage Theory of Grief
  10. OverYou (2026). Dataset: breakup and divorce search trends, US, October 2026 (CSV, CC BY 4.0)

Frequently asked questions

Is it true it takes half the relationship to get over someone?

No study supports that rule. Recovery varies a lot, and in one diary study love for an ex declined steadily over the first month after a breakup, while contact with the ex slowed that decline.

Do men get over breakups faster than women?

There is no good evidence for it. A large German study found no gender difference in changes in well-being or loneliness after a separation, though men were less likely to initiate it and wished for a new partner more.

Do on and off relationships ever work?

Some do, but on average they get worse: on-off partners report more uncertainty and communication problems, and more breakups and renewals go with more negatives and lower satisfaction.

OverYou is an app for keeping no contact: a streak, a 30-day program, a 30-second pause for when the urge hits, and a place to write the text instead of sending it. Get it on the App Store or Google Play, or see how it works.

OverYou Stop checking your ex, one day at a time.