OverYou

Does No Contact Work? What the Research Actually Says

· 7 min read · No contact

Mochi the cat adding a new ring to a long paper chain on the wall

This is a review of published research, not a new study. No one has run a trial in which people are randomly told to keep or break no contact, so the evidence below comes from surveys, follow-up studies and brain imaging. We say where each finding comes from and how strong it is. Full references are at the end.

"Go no contact" is the most common breakup advice online, and searches for "no contact rule" rose 85% in the US over the last five years, according to our analysis of Google Trends. But does it actually help you recover? We read the studies that come closest to answering that question.

The short answer

Yes, most likely, for recovery. No study has tested no contact directly, but several lines of research point the same way: continued contact with an ex, including just looking at their profile, goes with more distress and slower recovery, and the reward systems involved in missing an ex behave like cravings, which fade faster when they aren't fed. There's no good evidence that no contact makes an ex come back, and it isn't designed to.

Key findings

Mochi the cat adding a new ring to a long paper chain on the wall

What counts as contact in the research?

Most studies don't look at texting alone. They look at "surveillance": viewing an ex's profile, photos or stories, which most people don't think of as contact at all. That matters, because this kind of silent checking is the most common way people break no contact without noticing. Our guide to the no contact rule counts it as contact for this reason.

Marshall's 2012 study is the clearest. Among 464 people, Facebook surveillance of an ex went with more current distress over the breakup, more negative feelings, more desire and longing for the ex, and less personal growth. These results held after controlling for offline contact, personality and the features of the relationship. A 2015 study by Lukacs and Quan-Haase found the same pattern in young people: more surveillance of an ex, more breakup distress.

One detail is easy to miss. In Marshall's data, people who stayed Facebook friends with their ex reported slightly less longing than those who unfriended them, but also less personal growth. Unfriending in itself isn't the point; not checking is. That's why our guide to unfollowing your ex recommends muting as an option, as long as you stop looking.

Why does checking keep the pain going?

Because it works like a craving. Fisher and colleagues scanned the brains of 15 people who had recently been rejected but were still intensely in love. Looking at a photo of their ex activated the ventral tegmental area and ventral striatum, which are part of the brain's reward system, along with areas linked to cocaine craving and addiction. The authors suggest this may explain the obsessive thinking and checking after rejection.

Cravings tend to weaken when they go unrewarded and stay strong when they're fed now and then. Each look at an ex's profile, each reply and each "just checking in" can act as that occasional reward. This is the main reason no contact is usually advised for a set period with no exceptions, rather than "less contact". There's more on the brain side in why breakups hurt so much.

Does the urge to check fade?

The research suggests distress comes first and checking follows. Fox and Tokunaga found that the more upset people were after a breakup, the more they monitored their ex, especially if they hadn't chosen the breakup. McDaniel and colleagues found that two groups had the most distress: "impulsives", who did a lot of everything online, and "wistful reminiscers", who kept watching and interacting with their ex and their ex's friends. "Clean breakers", who mostly stopped, had the least.

These are surveys, so they can't prove that stopping causes recovery; upset people may simply check more. But it does mean the urge to check is a sign of distress, not a sign that you should reach out. The urge tends to be strongest in the first weeks, which is why a set period helps more than deciding each time.

What about getting back together?

Breaking up and reconciling is common. In a sample of 792 young adults who were dating or living together, nearly half reported at least one reconciliation, and more than half of those who broke up kept having sex with their ex (Halpern-Meekin and colleagues, 2013). In Dailey and colleagues' 2009 study, almost two thirds of 445 US college students had been in an on-off relationship, and on-off partners reported fewer positives (such as love and understanding) and more negatives (such as uncertainty and communication problems). More renewals went with more negatives.

No study shows that no contact makes an ex come back, and no contact used as a tactic tends to fail on its own terms, because you spend it watching for a reaction. Used for your own recovery, it's simply the space that on-off relationships never get. More in our guide to on-and-off relationships and will my ex come back?

Does counting the days help?

Probably, if you write it down. Harkin and colleagues pooled 138 randomized experiments with 19,951 people and found that interventions that got people to monitor their progress improved goal attainment, with an average effect size of d = 0.40. The effect was bigger when progress was physically recorded or shared with others. A daily check-in on a no contact streak is one simple form of this.

A slip doesn't wipe out the progress. In Lally and colleagues' study of how habits form, 96 people repeated a new daily behaviour for 12 weeks; missing a single day didn't materially affect how the habit built up. The same idea applies to breaking a habit: one message is a setback, not a reset to zero. Our guide to what to do if you broke no contact covers what to do next.

How long should no contact last?

The research doesn't give a number. Lally's habit study found that new habits took between 18 and 254 days to become automatic, which is a reminder that there's no universal timeline. Most breakup advice uses 30 days as a minimum and 60 to 90 days after a long relationship. A better test than the calendar is whether a message from your ex would leave you mostly neutral. See how long it takes to get over someone for what the studies say about recovery time.

When no contact isn't possible

The studies above are mostly about dating couples without children. If you share children, a workplace or a home, full no contact may not be possible or safe for the children. The same logic still applies to what you can control: keep contact to practical topics, and stop the checking. Our guides cover no contact with a child, an ex at work and still living with your ex.

Limits of the evidence

How OverYou uses this

OverYou is built around these findings. Your no contact streak is a daily check-in you record, which is the kind of progress monitoring Harkin's meta-analysis found most effective. When you want to check their profile, I'm tempted asks for a 30-second pause first and counts each urge you resist. A slip is marked on your calendar but doesn't erase the days before it. It's a self-care tool, not therapy.

Sources

  1. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking (2012). Facebook surveillance of former romantic partners: associations with postbreakup recovery and personal growth
  2. Information, Communication & Society (2015). Romantic breakups on Facebook: new scales for studying post-breakup behaviors, digital distress, and surveillance
  3. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking (2015). Romantic partner monitoring after breakups: attachment, dependence, distress, and post-dissolution online surveillance via social networking sites
  4. Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking (2021). Are You Going to Delete Me? Latent Profiles of Post-Relationship Breakup Social Media Use and Emotional Distress
  5. Journal of Neurophysiology (2010). Reward, addiction, and emotion regulation systems associated with rejection in love
  6. Journal of Adolescent Research (2013). Relationship churning in emerging adulthood: On/off relationships and sex with an ex
  7. Personal Relationships (2009). On-again/off-again dating relationships: How are they different from other dating relationships?
  8. Psychological Bulletin (2016). Does monitoring goal progress promote goal attainment? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence
  9. European Journal of Social Psychology (2010). How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world

Frequently asked questions

Does no contact actually work?

For recovery, the evidence points that way. No trial has tested it directly, but studies of hundreds of people link checking an ex's profile and staying in contact with more distress, more longing and less personal growth.

Is there scientific evidence for the no contact rule?

Indirect evidence. Survey studies link online checking of an ex with slower recovery, brain imaging shows that missing an ex activates craving systems, and on-off relationships report more uncertainty and conflict. There is no randomized trial.

Does no contact make your ex come back?

There's no evidence that it does, and it isn't designed to. Nearly half of young adults have reconciled with an ex at some point, but on-off relationships tend to have more negatives the more often they restart.

OverYou is an app for keeping no contact: a streak, a 30-day program, a 30-second pause for when the urge hits, and a place to write the text instead of sending it. Get it on the App Store or Google Play, or see how it works.

OverYou Stop checking your ex, one day at a time.