Does Writing About a Breakup Help? What Expressive Writing Research Says
This is a review of published research on expressive writing and breakups, not a new study. We summarize what each study found, including one that found writing made things worse for some people. Full references are at the end.
Journaling, unsent letters and "write it all down" are among the most common pieces of breakup advice. Writing about painful experiences is also one of the most studied self-help techniques in psychology, with well over a hundred experiments. So does it help after a breakup? Mostly yes, but the research shows that how you write matters more than whether you write.
The short answer
Writing about a breakup helps on average, but the effect is small, and not every kind of writing helps everyone. Writing about what you've gained or learned raised positive feelings after a breakup, and reflecting on the breakup helped people rebuild a clearer sense of who they are. But in one trial, people who were still searching hard for the meaning of their separation did worse after classic "write your deepest feelings" sessions. Short, structured writing that moves toward the future seems safer than reliving the pain again and again.
Key findings
- Writing helps a little, on average. A meta-analysis of 146 randomized studies found a small positive effect of writing about emotional experiences (r = 0.075) (Frattaroli, 2006).
- It can feel worse before it feels better. An earlier meta-analysis found writing improved health outcomes but also raised distress right after writing, which didn't predict worse outcomes (Smyth, 1998).
- Positive writing helped after a breakup. Among 87 people who had recently gone through a breakup, those who wrote about positive aspects of it gained more positive emotion than those who wrote negatively or neutrally (Lewandowski, 2009).
- Classic expressive writing backfired for some. In a trial with 90 recently separated adults, those actively searching for meaning in the separation reported worse emotional outcomes up to nine months later after expressive writing than after neutral writing (Sbarra and colleagues, 2013).
- Reflecting on the breakup helped people find themselves again. Among 210 recently separated young adults, those who reflected on the breakup more often in a study recovered a clearer sense of self, which went with less loneliness and fewer intrusive thoughts (Larson and Sbarra, 2015).
- Naming feelings calms the brain. Putting a feeling into words reduced activity in the amygdala, the brain's alarm system, in an imaging study (Lieberman and colleagues, 2007).
Where the idea comes from
In a 1986 experiment, James Pennebaker and Sandra Beall asked students to write about a traumatic experience for 15 minutes on four days in a row. Students who wrote about both the facts and their feelings visited the health centre less often in the following months than those who wrote about trivial topics. That study started a large research field on "expressive writing".
Decades later, the effect has held up, but it's smaller than early studies suggested. Smyth's 1998 meta-analysis found that writing improved reported physical health, psychological well-being and general functioning in healthy people. Frattaroli's 2006 meta-analysis of 146 randomized studies found a positive but small average effect, r = 0.075. Both found that writing often raises distress right afterwards. That short-term dip is normal and, in Smyth's analysis, unrelated to the long-term benefit.
What the breakup studies found
Writing about the upside raised positive feelings
Gary Lewandowski randomly assigned 87 single people who had recently been through a breakup to write about its negative aspects, its positive aspects, or a neutral topic. Those who wrote about the positives, such as what they'd learned or gained, showed a bigger increase in positive emotions right afterwards than the other two groups. Negative emotions didn't differ between the groups. In other words, writing about the good side didn't erase the sadness, but it added something.
This matches other research. Tashiro and Frazier (2003) found that 92 students who had recently broken up reported, on average, five kinds of personal growth they thought would improve future relationships. Lewandowski and Bizzoco (2007) found that growth after a breakup was linked to rediscovering parts of yourself that a low-quality relationship had pushed aside.
For some people, reliving it made things worse
Sbarra and colleagues ran a trial with 90 adults who had recently separated from a spouse. They wrote in one of three ways: traditional expressive writing about their deepest feelings, a narrative version that asked them to tell the story of the separation, or neutral control writing. Up to nine months later, people who were actively searching for the meaning of their separation had worse emotional outcomes if they'd done either kind of expressive writing than if they'd done the control writing.
The authors' interpretation is that for people already stuck turning the "why" over and over, being asked to go deeper into it can feed rumination rather than resolve it. This is the most important caution in the research: if writing leaves you more stuck each time, change how you write or stop.
Reflection helped rebuild who you are
Larson and Sbarra followed 210 young adults after a breakup for nine weeks. 120 of them came in four times for detailed sessions about the breakup and how they were coping; the other 90 only came at the start and the end. The group that reflected more often regained a clearer sense of who they were, and that change explained their drop in emotional intrusion and loneliness. They also used "we" less when describing the separation. A clearer sense of self matters because losing it is one of the strongest predictors of distress after a breakup (Slotter and colleagues, 2010).
Why writing might help
One reason is that it puts feelings into words. In Lieberman and colleagues' imaging study, labeling an emotion reduced the amygdala's response to upsetting images, compared with other ways of looking at them. Another is that writing can turn a loop of thoughts into a story with an ending. And for many people after a breakup, the urge to write is really the urge to text: writing the message down without sending it can meet that need without restarting contact. We cover that in the research on the urge to text your ex.
How to write about a breakup, based on the research
- Keep it short and time-limited. The classic studies used 15 to 20 minutes a session over a few days, not hours every day.
- Include what you've learned or gained. Lewandowski's positive-writing group was the one that felt better.
- Write toward the future, not only the past. What you want next, what you'd do differently, who you are now.
- Notice if you're going round in circles. If each session leaves you more stuck on "why", switch to a different kind of writing or take a break, as Sbarra's trial suggests.
- Don't send it. A letter you write to your ex is for you. Our guide to writing an unsent letter has prompts.
Limits of the evidence
- Most breakup studies were small (87 to 210 people) and many used university students.
- Lewandowski measured emotions right after writing, not weeks later.
- The overall effect of expressive writing is small. It's a helpful habit, not a treatment for depression. If you feel persistently low, talk to a doctor or therapist.
How OverYou uses this
OverYou has two places to write. Don't Send It is for the message you want to send your ex: you can say everything, and it never leaves your phone. The 30-day program uses short, structured writing rather than open-ended writing about the past: one day you name how you feel in a single word, another you write what you'd tell a friend in your place, and at the end of each week you answer three questions: what was hardest, what helped, and one thing to try next week. The journal keeps it all, with a selfie, so you can see how far you've come.
Sources
- Journal of Abnormal Psychology (1986). Confronting a traumatic event: toward an understanding of inhibition and disease
- Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology (1998). Written emotional expression: effect sizes, outcome types, and moderating variables
- Psychological Bulletin (2006). Experimental disclosure and its moderators: a meta-analysis
- The Journal of Positive Psychology (2009). Promoting positive emotions following relationship dissolution through writing
- Clinical Psychological Science (2013). Expressive writing can impede emotional recovery following marital separation
- Social Psychological and Personality Science (2015). Participating in Research on Romantic Breakups Promotes Emotional Recovery via Changes in Self-Concept Clarity
- Personal Relationships (2003). "I'll never be in a relationship like that again": Personal growth following romantic relationship breakups
- The Journal of Positive Psychology (2007). Addition through subtraction: Growth following the dissolution of a low quality relationship
- Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin (2010). Who am I without you? The influence of romantic breakup on the self-concept
- Psychological Science (2007). Putting feelings into words: affect labeling disrupts amygdala activity in response to affective stimuli
Frequently asked questions
Does journaling help after a breakup?
On average, yes, a little. Writing about what you gained from a breakup increased positive emotions in a 2009 study, and reflecting on a breakup helped people regain a clearer sense of who they are. The overall effect of expressive writing is small.
Can writing about a breakup make it worse?
Sometimes. In a 2013 trial, separated adults who were stuck searching for the meaning of their separation did worse up to nine months later after expressive writing than after neutral writing.
Should I write a letter to my ex and not send it?
It can help if the urge to text is really an urge to say something. Keep it for yourself, include what you've learned, and stop if writing leaves you more stuck each time.
OverYou is an app for keeping no contact: a streak, a 30-day program, a 30-second pause for when the urge hits, and a place to write the text instead of sending it. Get it on the App Store or Google Play, or see how it works.