OverYou

Should I Get Back With My Ex? Questions to Ask First

· 6 min read · Missing your ex

Mochi the cat with a paw on the handle of a door left slightly open

Maybe they've reached out. Maybe they haven't, and you're wondering whether you should. Either way, the question keeps coming back: should we try again? You remember how good it was, and you're tired of how much it hurts to be apart.

This guide won't tell you what to do. It will tell you what the research says about couples who get back together, and give you questions to answer honestly before you decide.

Should you get back with your ex?

Only if the reason you broke up has actually changed, and you can both say what's different now. Getting back together is common, and some couples do better the second time. But on average, couples who break up and reunite report more uncertainty and lower satisfaction than couples who don't. Missing them is not, on its own, a good enough reason.

If you were afraid of your ex, or the relationship was controlling, this guide isn't the right one. Read getting over a toxic relationship instead.

How common is getting back together?

Very common. In a sample of 792 young adults who were dating or living together, nearly half had broken up and got back together at least once, and more than half of those who broke up kept having sex with their ex (Halpern-Meekin and colleagues, 2013). In Dailey and colleagues' 2009 study, almost two thirds of 445 US college students had been in an on-again, off-again relationship.

It doesn't stop at dating. In a nationally representative US sample of 323 cohabiting and 752 married couples, over a third of cohabiters and about a fifth of spouses said they had broken up and got back together in their current relationship (Vennum and colleagues, 2014). So if you're thinking about it, you're far from alone.

Why do people get back together?

Mostly because the feelings didn't go away. Dailey and colleagues (2011) asked 274 people who had been in on-off relationships why they renewed them. Lingering feelings were a main reason. Renewals were also more likely when people were unsure what the breakup had meant, when they hadn't dated anyone else in between, and when they felt the breaks had improved the relationship.

Notice that most of those are about feelings and uncertainty, not about problems being solved. That's the risk. The relief of being back together is real, but it can feel like proof you belong together when it's mostly proof that the breakup hurt. Our guide to will my ex come back? covers that waiting feeling.

Mochi the cat stepping out of a revolving door and pausing on the pavement

Do couples who get back together last?

Some do. Many struggle. The research points to a pattern: the more times a couple breaks up and reunites, the worse things tend to get.

These are survey studies, so they show what goes together, not what causes what. Couples who were already struggling may simply be the ones who break up more. Still, the message is consistent: a reunion that skips over the old problems tends to bring them back.

Questions to ask before you get back together

Answer these on a calm day, in writing if you can. Not at midnight, and not right after they've messaged you.

  1. Why did it end? Write the real reason in one or two sentences. If you can't, you're not ready to decide.
  2. What has changed since then? Not what they've promised. What has actually been different, for how long, and how do you know?
  3. Have you talked about it together? In Dailey and colleagues' 2012 interviews with 65 people in on-off relationships, some partners resolved past problems and planned for new ones when they renewed. Reunions that skip this step usually repeat the old ending.
  4. Do you miss them, or the feeling of not being alone? Those are different. Loneliness can be met in other ways. See loneliness after a breakup, or regret versus loneliness after a breakup if you're not sure which one you're feeling.
  5. Is this the first time, or the fourth? One reunion after a real change is different from a fourth round of the same pattern.
  6. Would you feel secure, or would you be waiting for the next ending? Picture six months from now, honestly.
  7. What do your closest friends think? You don't have to follow their advice, but if everyone who loves you is worried, ask why.

Signs it might work

Signs it probably won't

If this sounds like your pattern, our guide to on-and-off relationships covers how to break the cycle.

What if you're not sure yet?

Take time before you decide. A period of no contact, used for yourself rather than as a tactic, gives you the space to see the relationship clearly. If they've already messaged, you don't need to answer straight away. Our guide on what to do when your ex texts you can help.

If you share children, a home or a workplace, you may need some contact anyway. Keep it practical while you think. And if the back-and-forth is making it hard to sleep, work or eat, talking to a therapist can help you sort out what you want.

Limits of the research

How OverYou helps

If you're taking time to decide, OverYou keeps a daily no contact streak and gives you a 30-second pause when you're tempted to reach out, then asks what you're hoping to find. Evidence keeps the reasons it ended in one place, so you can reread them before you decide. You can also talk it through with Mochi, the app's AI coach. It's self-care, not therapy.

Sources

  1. Journal of Adolescent Research (2013). Relationship churning in emerging adulthood: On/off relationships and sex with an ex
  2. Personal Relationships (2009). On-again/off-again dating relationships: How are they different from other dating relationships?
  3. The Journal of Social Psychology (2011). On-again/off-again dating relationships: What keeps partners coming back?
  4. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships (2014). "It's complicated": The continuity and correlates of cycling in cohabiting and marital relationships
  5. Family Relations (2018). Coming out and getting back in: Relationship cycling and distress in same- and different-sex relationships
  6. Western Journal of Communication (2013). Negotiating breakups and renewals: Types of on-again/off-again dating relationships

Frequently asked questions

Is it a good idea to get back with an ex?

It can be, if the reason you broke up has truly changed and you have talked it through. On average, though, research links breaking up and reuniting with more uncertainty, lower satisfaction and more distress.

Do couples who get back together last?

Some do, but repeated breakups and reunions tend to go with more negatives and fewer positives, and couples who have cycled once are at greater risk of doing it again.

Why do people get back with their ex?

Mostly because of lingering feelings. Research also links reunions with being unsure what the breakup meant and with not dating anyone else in between.

OverYou is an app for keeping no contact: a streak, a 30-day program, a 30-second pause for when the urge hits, and a place to write the text instead of sending it. Get it on the App Store or Google Play, or see how it works.

OverYou Stop checking your ex, one day at a time.