OverYou

Do Rebound Relationships Work? What the Research Says

· 7 min read · Getting over a breakup

Mochi the cat watching a ball bounce back off a wall

This is a review of published research, not a new study. All the studies below are surveys or short experiments, so they show what tends to go together, not what will happen to you. Full references are at the end.

The common view is that rebound relationships are a bad idea: you're using someone to avoid your feelings, and it won't last. Your friends may have said it. You may have said it about your ex. But what does the research actually say about rebounds?

Less than you'd think, and it's more positive than the reputation. If you're still deciding whether to date at all, start with when to start dating after a breakup. This guide is about the evidence on rebounds, and how to tell whether yours is helping.

The short answer

Rebounds can work, in the sense that many people feel better, not worse. People who start a new relationship after a breakup tend to feel more desirable and more over their ex, and they tend to see a smaller drop in life satisfaction. What hurts is not the speed. It's starting something mainly out of fear of being alone, or using a new person only as a distraction. Those motives go with settling and with longing for the ex.

What counts as a rebound relationship?

In research, a rebound is usually defined as a relationship that starts soon after a breakup, before your feelings about the last one are resolved (Brumbaugh and Fraley, 2015). In everyday speech it also often means something casual: a fling or a few hookups to feel wanted again. Studies don't always separate the two, and that matters, because a short fling and a serious new partner can feel very different.

Do rebound relationships work?

The best direct study is Brumbaugh and Fraley's 2015 paper, which they titled "Too fast, too soon?". Across two studies of people who had been through a breakup, those in a new relationship were more confident in their own desirability and had more resolution about their ex. Among people in new relationships, starting sooner was linked with better psychological and relationship health, not worse. The authors concluded that rebounds may be more beneficial than people usually think.

A larger study points the same way. Rhoades and colleagues (2011) followed 1,295 unmarried 18- to 35-year-olds in the US and compared the same people before and after a breakup. Breaking up went with more distress and lower life satisfaction. But people who had started dating someone new had smaller declines in life satisfaction. Those who had lived together or planned to marry had larger ones. There's more from this study in our breakup statistics.

One caution: these are correlations. People who were already coping well may simply be the ones who started dating sooner. The studies show that rebounds are not the disaster they're said to be. They don't show that dating quickly makes you heal.

Mochi the cat peeking cautiously at a phone screen with a few hearts on it

Why might a rebound help?

One reason is that it gives your attention and hope somewhere new to go. Spielmann, MacDonald and Wilson (2009) looked at anxiously attached people, the ones who tend to worry about being left and to hold on hardest to an ex. Normally, more anxious attachment goes with more longing for an ex. But in their survey that link was broken for people who had a new partner.

Then they tested it. In two experiments, they led anxiously attached people to believe they could easily find a new partner, once with made-up feedback and once with a simple memory task. That alone made them less attached to their ex. The authors suggest that, for anxious people especially, focusing on someone new can be a healthy part of recovery. Note that the experiments changed beliefs about future partners, not actual dating, so a feeling of "there are other people for me" may be the active part.

When does a rebound hurt?

The research suggests the motive matters more than the timing.

So the question isn't "is it too soon?" but "why am I doing this?" A rebound that comes from curiosity about a new person is different from one that comes from panic about being alone or a wish to stop feeling anything.

Are rebound relationships doomed to fail?

There's no good evidence either way. The studies above look at how people feel, not at how long rebound relationships last, and we couldn't find a solid study that follows rebounds over years. The idea that they always fail is folk wisdom. Some end quickly, which may be fine if it was a bridge you needed. Some become long relationships. If you're asking this about your ex's new partner, see what to do when your ex moves on.

How to tell if your rebound is helping

  1. Check your motive. Finish the sentence: "I'm seeing this person because…" If the honest answer is mostly about your ex (to forget them, to make them jealous, to prove you're fine), slow down.
  2. Notice how you feel afterwards. After time together, do you feel lighter, or emptier and more focused on your ex? Your mood the next morning tells you more than the first rush.
  3. Watch where the comparisons go. Comparing now and then is normal. Comparing every moment, or talking about your ex a lot, is a sign the space isn't empty yet.
  4. Ask the disappearing test. If this person left tomorrow, would you miss them, or would the old breakup come flooding back? The second answer means the rebound is holding up the grief rather than replacing it.
  5. Keep your own life going. Friends, sleep and your own plans shouldn't vanish into the new relationship. In Shimek and Bello's study, low social support went with rebounding as a distraction, so friends are part of the protection.
  6. Keep no contact with your ex. Dating someone new is not a reason to tell your ex or to check whether they've seen. See the no contact rule.

Be fair to the new person

You don't owe a new date your whole story. But if you know this is casual for you, say so. "I'm just out of something and not looking for anything serious" is honest and kind. If they want more than you can give right now, it's better for both of you to know early.

Is it okay not to rebound?

Yes. The studies show rebounds aren't harmful on average, not that everyone should have one. Plenty of people take months or longer before dating again and do well. Our guide to loneliness after a breakup covers the empty evenings that often push people to date before they want to.

Limits of the evidence

How OverYou helps

OverYou won't tell you whether to date. It helps with the part that decides whether a rebound helps or hurts: your link to your ex. Your no contact streak and "I'm tempted" pause help you keep that door closed, and the Journal lets you note one word a day, so you can see whether the new person is making you feel lighter or not. It's self-care, not therapy.

Sources

  1. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships (2015). Too fast, too soon? An empirical investigation into rebound relationships
  2. Journal of Family Psychology (2011). Breaking up is hard to do: The impact of unmarried relationship dissolution on mental health and life satisfaction
  3. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin (2009). On the rebound: Focusing on someone new helps anxiously attached individuals let go of ex-partners
  4. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2013). Settling for less out of fear of being single
  5. Journal of Personality (2016). Longing for ex-partners out of fear of being single
  6. Social Sciences (2014). Coping with break-ups: Rebound relationships and gender socialization

Frequently asked questions

Do rebound relationships work?

Often, yes, in terms of how people feel. Studies find that people in a new relationship after a breakup are more confident in their desirability and more resolved about their ex, though the evidence is correlational.

Are rebound relationships healthy?

They can be. Research suggests the reason matters more than the timing: a rebound out of interest in someone new seems fine, while one driven by fear of being single goes with settling for less.

How long do rebound relationships last?

There's no good evidence on how long rebounds last. Studies have measured how people feel after a breakup, not whether the new relationship survives, so the idea that rebounds always fail is folk wisdom.

OverYou is an app for keeping no contact: a streak, a 30-day program, a 30-second pause for when the urge hits, and a place to write the text instead of sending it. Get it on the App Store or Google Play, or see how it works.

OverYou Stop checking your ex, one day at a time.