Should You Think About Your Ex's Flaws? What Love Regulation Research Says
This is a review of published research on "love regulation", the study of whether people can deliberately weaken or strengthen romantic feelings. It's a small field, so we describe each study and its limits. Full references are at the end.
"Make a list of everything that was wrong with them" is classic breakup advice. It sounds a little bitter, and you might wonder whether it just makes you feel worse. A small set of experiments has tested exactly this. The answer is that it works, and it does make you feel a bit worse, which is why it pairs well with something else.
The short answer
Thinking about your ex's negative qualities does reduce love feelings for them, according to experiments by Sandra Langeslag and colleagues. But it also makes you feel more unpleasant in the moment. Distraction does the opposite: it doesn't change how in love you feel, but it improves your mood. Used together, deliberately and in small doses, they cover both problems after a breakup: still loving them, and feeling bad.
Key findings
- People believe love can't be controlled, but it can, somewhat. Participants saw love feelings as somewhat uncontrollable, yet instructed regulation changed their reported feelings of infatuation and attachment (Langeslag and van Strien, 2016).
- Thinking about the ex's flaws reduces love feelings. In an experiment with people upset about a breakup, "negative reappraisal" of the ex decreased love feelings (Langeslag and Sanchez, 2018).
- It also makes you feel worse, for now. The same strategy made participants feel more unpleasant (Langeslag and Sanchez, 2018).
- Distraction lifts mood but not love. Thinking about something pleasant and unrelated made participants feel more pleasant without changing love feelings (Langeslag and Sanchez, 2018).
- All strategies reduced attention to the ex. Brain recordings showed less "motivated attention" to the ex's photo after each strategy, which could make reminders easier to handle (Langeslag and Sanchez, 2018).
- Memory after a breakup is often one-sided. Missing an ex involves reward and craving systems in the brain (Fisher and colleagues, 2010), which may help explain why the good memories come back more easily than the reasons it ended.
What is love regulation?
Psychologists have long studied how people regulate emotions like anger or fear. Sandra Langeslag and Jan van Strien proposed applying the same idea to romantic love: using deliberate thoughts or behaviour to change how intense your love feelings are. In their 2016 studies, people said they felt love was somewhat uncontrollable. Yet when asked how they coped with breakups, they described strategies such as rethinking the relationship, distraction, avoiding the person and taking up new activities. When participants were instructed to turn their love feelings down, reported infatuation and attachment decreased.
The breakup experiment
In a study published in 2018, Langeslag and Michelle Sanchez recruited people who were upset about a romantic breakup. Before viewing photos of their ex while their brain activity was recorded, participants used one of three strategies:
- Negative reappraisal: thinking about the ex's negative qualities or annoying habits, or about bad moments in the relationship.
- Love reappraisal: accepting the love feelings, for example by telling themselves that it's fine to still love someone after a breakup.
- Distraction: thinking about something pleasant that had nothing to do with the ex.
Each did something different. Negative reappraisal decreased love feelings for the ex and made participants feel more unpleasant. Love reappraisal didn't change how in love or how pleasant they felt. Distraction didn't change love feelings but made participants feel more pleasant. All three reduced the late positive potential, a brain signal of how much attention something grabs, when participants looked at their ex.
The authors concluded that after a breakup, negative reappraisal is an effective way to turn love down, and distraction is an effective way to turn positive mood up.
Why the bad parts are easy to forget
After a breakup, many people find that their memory replays the good moments and skips the reasons it ended. Brain research doesn't measure this directly, but it fits what's known about missing someone: in Fisher and colleagues' 2010 study, looking at a rejecting partner activated reward and craving systems. When you're craving something, you tend to remember why you wanted it, not why you stopped. A written list of reasons is a way of keeping the other half of the picture available when your memory isn't offering it. There's more on this in why you still miss your ex.
How to use this without getting bitter
- Write the list once, then refer to it. Writing the reasons down means you don't have to dwell on them every day. Read it when the nostalgia hits, not as a daily ritual.
- Be accurate, not cruel. The study used real negative qualities and bad moments, not insults. "They never made plans with my friends" is more useful than "they're awful".
- Follow it with something pleasant. Because reappraisal lowers mood and distraction raises it, pairing them makes sense: read your list, then call a friend, go outside or watch something you enjoy.
- Be kind to yourself, too. Self-compassion is one of the best-supported predictors of recovery: divorcing adults who talked about their separation with more self-compassion had fewer intrusive thoughts about it up to nine months later (Sbarra and colleagues, 2012).
- Don't use it to stay connected. A list is for you. Going over their flaws with friends every day, or checking their profile for new ones, keeps them at the centre of your attention. See what the research says about no contact.
Limits of the evidence
- The research comes mainly from one lab and from small laboratory samples. The effects were measured over minutes, not weeks.
- Lowering love feelings isn't the same as recovering. It's one tool among several, alongside time, support and rebuilding your own life.
- If you were in an abusive relationship, the issue isn't remembering the bad parts. Reach out to a local domestic violence helpline for support.
How OverYou uses this
Evidence in OverYou is a short, private list of the reasons it ended, written for the moments you forget. Day 3 of the 30-day program asks you to add three things to it, and then do one nice thing for yourself for ten minutes, which is the pairing this research suggests: reappraisal for the love feelings, something pleasant for the mood. Everything you write stays on your phone. For more ways to get your mind back, see how to stop thinking about your ex.
Sources
- Journal of Experimental Psychology: General (2018). Down-regulation of love feelings after a romantic break-up: Self-report and electrophysiological data
- PLOS ONE (2016). Regulation of romantic love feelings: preconceptions, strategies, and feasibility
- Journal of Neurophysiology (2010). Reward, addiction, and emotion regulation systems associated with rejection in love
- Psychological Science (2012). When leaving your ex, love yourself: observational ratings of self-compassion predict the course of emotional recovery following marital separation
Frequently asked questions
Does thinking about your ex's flaws help you get over them?
Yes, in part. In a 2018 experiment, thinking about an ex's negative qualities reduced love feelings for them, but it also made people feel worse in the moment. Following it with something pleasant helps with the mood.
Can you make yourself fall out of love?
To a degree. Experiments by Sandra Langeslag found that people can turn love feelings down on purpose, mainly by deliberately rethinking the relationship, although people tend to believe love is uncontrollable.
Should I make a list of reasons we broke up?
It can help, as long as it's accurate rather than cruel and you use it when you miss them, not as a daily ritual. Pair it with something you enjoy, since reappraisal lowers mood.
OverYou is an app for keeping no contact: a streak, a 30-day program, a 30-second pause for when the urge hits, and a place to write the text instead of sending it. Get it on the App Store or Google Play, or see how it works.