How to Get Over a Situationship (When It Was Never Official)
It was more than friends and less than a relationship. You talked most days, maybe slept over, maybe met their friends. But nobody ever said what it was, and now it's over, or fading, and you're not even sure you're allowed to call it a breakup.
You are. Getting over a situationship is its own kind of hard, and research on uncertainty and one-sided love helps explain why. This guide covers what the studies say and what to do, step by step. If what you had was more of a long crush with little real contact, our guide to getting over someone you never dated may fit better.
The short answer
Treat it like a breakup, because to your mind it is one. Give yourself a clear ending, since they probably won't. Take a set period of no contact, including no checking their profile. And spend less time decoding what it meant, because the not knowing is a big part of what keeps you hooked.
Is the end of a situationship a real breakup?
Emotionally, yes. You were attached to a person, you had a routine with them, and you had hopes about where it was going. Losing that is a loss, whatever the label said.
What makes it different is the lack of clarity. Psychologist Pauline Boss uses the term "ambiguous loss" for losses that come without clear facts or an ending, and she describes the grief that follows as complicated, because there is nothing clear to grieve (Boss, 2010). Her work is mostly about very different situations, such as missing family members, so a situationship is not the same thing. But the core problem is similar: you're grieving something that was never confirmed, and nobody hands you an ending.
There is also less support. Friends know what to say after a three-year relationship ends. After "we were sort of seeing each other", they might say it shouldn't hurt this much. That's not true, and it's worth finding one person who doesn't minimize it.
Why can a situationship hurt as much as a relationship?
Because uncertainty makes feelings stronger, not weaker. Several studies point the same way.
- Not knowing turns up the volume. In four experiments, Bar-Anan and colleagues (2009) found that simply feeling uncertain while watching a film made people's emotional reactions stronger, both good and bad. A situationship is months of that feeling.
- Mixed signals pull you in. In a study by Whitchurch and colleagues (2011), college women who weren't sure whether a man liked them a lot or only an average amount ended up the most attracted to him, more than women told he liked them a lot. They also thought about him the most, and that thinking explained the extra attraction.
- Uncertainty goes with anger and sadness. When 141 people in dating relationships described events that made them less sure about the relationship, those events went with more anger and sadness (Knobloch and Solomon, 2003).
- The ending is often never said. In Baumeister and colleagues' 1993 study of unrequited love, the people who were rejected often believed the attraction had been mutual, felt they had been led on, and said the rejection had never been clearly communicated.
Put together, this explains a lot. The same uncertainty that made the situationship exciting is what makes it so hard to put down. Your mind keeps the file open because it never got an answer.
Why can't I stop thinking about them?
Part of it is the uncertainty above. Part of it may be fear of being alone. In a 2016 study, Spielmann and colleagues followed 117 people through the month after a breakup. On days when fear of being single was stronger, people longed more for their ex and tried harder to get back together. Fear of being single also rose after the breakup, whoever ended it.
That matters for situationships, because the hope that it might still turn into something is easy to keep alive. Each "hey stranger" message or story view feeds it. If you notice the thought "maybe if I just…", it helps to ask whether you miss this person, or whether you're scared of the empty space.
How do you get over a situationship?
- Decide the answer yourself. You may never hear "this is over" from them. Say it to yourself, in a full sentence: "It ended, and I'm not waiting for it to restart." You can send a short, kind message if you want to, but you don't need their agreement for it to be over.
- Write down what it actually was. Not what you hoped. How often did they make plans? Who reached out first? What did they say when you asked where it was going, if you ever did? Facts on paper are harder for hope to argue with.
- Pick a no contact period and start today. Thirty days is a common minimum. Stop messaging, mute their accounts, and don't reply to the occasional check-in.
- Plan for your hardest hour. Most people have one: late at night, or the time they used to talk. Make an if-then plan: "If I want to message them at 11 p.m., I'll write it in my notes app instead and go to bed."
- Give the questions a time slot. If you keep replaying what it meant, set aside ten minutes a day to think about it on purpose, then stop. It's easier to postpone a thought when you know it has a place.
- Ask what you'd tell a friend. If a friend described this exact situation to you, what would you say? Write that down and read it when you're tempted to go back.
- Put the attention back somewhere. A situationship takes a lot of mental energy. Give some of it to sleep, friends, exercise or a project, even in small amounts.
Do you need no contact if you were never official?
Yes, if you want to move on. The lack of a label is exactly why situationships drift back. A like on your post or a late-night "thinking of you" costs them nothing and can restart weeks of hoping for you. The research on breakups points the same way: in a study of 464 people, checking an ex's Facebook went with more distress and longing and less personal growth (Marshall, 2012). Everything in the no contact rule applies here.
If you share a friend group, a class or a job, you can still keep contact friendly and short, and stop the private messages and the checking. When they do reach out, our guide on what to do when your ex texts you works for situationships too.
Should you ask them what it was?
Only if you can accept any answer, including a vague one. Many people in situationships ask "what are we?" hoping the answer will finally fix the uncertainty. Often it just adds a new round of it. If you decide to talk, keep it to one honest conversation, then step back whatever they say. Our guide to getting closure covers how to give yourself an ending without them.
And if this one has ended and restarted a few times, read on-and-off relationships. The pattern of almost-ending and coming back is common, and it rarely becomes clearer with each round.
What to take into the next one
Once it hurts less, it's worth asking one question: what did you need that you didn't ask for? Many people realize they wanted clarity months earlier and stayed quiet, afraid the question would end it. Next time you can ask sooner. An answer you don't like early on costs less than a long time without one.
When to get help
Heartbreak is painful, but if you can't sleep or eat for weeks, can't get through work or classes, or have thoughts of harming yourself, please talk to a doctor or a mental health professional, or contact a local helpline. Needing help after something "unofficial" isn't an overreaction.
How OverYou helps
OverYou gives you a no contact streak with a daily check-in, so the ending you decided on has something to hold onto. When you want to message them, "I'm tempted" asks for a 30-second pause and then asks what you're hoping to find, and "Don't Send It" lets you write the message without it ever leaving your phone. The 30-day program includes the if-then plan, the worry window and the friend exercise above. It's self-care, not therapy.
Sources
- Emotion (2009). The feeling of uncertainty intensifies affective reactions
- Psychological Science (2011). "He loves me, he loves me not . . . ": Uncertainty can increase romantic attraction
- Communication Studies (2003). Responses to changes in relational uncertainty within dating relationships: Emotions and communication strategies
- Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (1993). Unrequited love: On heartbreak, anger, guilt, scriptlessness, and humiliation
- Journal of Personality (2016). Longing for ex-partners out of fear of being single
- Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking (2012). Facebook surveillance of former romantic partners: associations with postbreakup recovery and personal growth
Frequently asked questions
Why does a situationship hurt so much?
Because uncertainty makes feelings stronger. In experiments, not knowing intensified people's emotional reactions, and women unsure whether a man liked them thought about him more and were more attracted to him.
Do you need no contact after a situationship?
If you want to move on, yes. Without a label, small messages and likes can restart the hope, and checking an ex's profile is linked with more distress and longing.
How long does it take to get over a situationship?
There's no set time, and no study has measured it for situationships. It usually gets easier once you stop waiting for an answer from them and stop checking on them.
OverYou is an app for keeping no contact: a streak, a 30-day program, a 30-second pause for when the urge hits, and a place to write the text instead of sending it. Get it on the App Store or Google Play, or see how it works.